Thanks capgun! It was even worse than I originally thought. Much of that paint could be scratched off with a fingernail so it was definitely time to fully restore it. I was quite surprised how well that wheel half cleaned up. All I can say is they must have used some really good chrome back then. All that rust is just sitting on the surface. There are a few tiny black specs where it ate through the chrome but by the time the aluminum center hubs are bolted back in they will not be noticeable and the other two halves are much better than the one I cleaned up already.