When I said "wire brush" I was refering to one I use at high RPM on aluminum just before I switch to the buffing pad and rouge. I don't do chrome with a wire brush that would make a mark on it.
Dont be afraid of the paint stripper on your chrome. We used it on aircraft aluminum- and I use it on everything, even plastic and FRP if you don't keep it on too long.
I use an estimated 25% ratio of muriatic to water. I hang the parts using a wire (coat hanger, etc) in the solution for only as long as it takes to see the rust beginning to fade. I then take it out and wash it with dish soap and water, using a piece of steel wool as a rag. If it takes the rust off, good, if not, it goes back in the acid. I have never eaten into any chrome, or melted any metal, except for one time I left a piece in over night, and I could see a line where the level of acid was. (not a chrome piece)
You have to wash it with soap and water. I used to neutralize with soda ash and water, (pool chemicals again, LOL) but didnt see any difference from soap and water. You also must dry it with compressed air or a rag, or it will be prone to rusting. Note that I have never experienced bare metal rusting while sitting in my garage. I also dont use a water separator on my air compressor, and I know that a rag soaked in reducer is dry in about a minute. We live in a DRY climate.
PS: In the time it has taken me to type this, I could have had both of those fenders done. LOL!
PPS: Evapo-rust is the stuff most people use- but it's expensive, and in AZ, you can't put it on a soak-rag and hope to do anything with it.
PPPS: By this time, with the old OldMiniBikes, someone would have mentioned using coca-cola and tin foil.